The Second Deputy Chairman of Ways and Means took the Chair as Deputy Speaker ( Standing Order No. 3 ). I beg to move, That the House sit in private. Question put forthwith ( Standing Order No. 163 ).

20 March 2009 #12837

Ayes

Noes

Majority

FAIL

Result

Party breakdown

Party	Aye	No	Total
CON Conservative	0	20	20
LD Liberal Democrat	2	18	20
LAB Labour	0	18	18
UNK Unknown	0	5	5
IND Independent	0	1	1
SPE Speaker	0	1	1

65 recorded

MP	Party	Constituency	Vote
Albert Owen	LAB		NO
Alistair Burt	CON		NO
Annette Brooke	LD		NO
Barbara Keeley			NO
Ben Gummer	CON		NO
Charles Hendry	CON		NO
Chris McCafferty	LAB		NO
Dame Angela Watkinson	CON		NO
Dame Joan Ruddock	LAB		NO
Damian Green	CON		NO
Danny Alexander	LD		NO
David Howarth	LD		NO
Dr David Drew	LAB		NO
Dr Evan Harris	LD		NO
Fiona Mactaggart	LAB		NO
Frank Dobson	LAB		NO
Greg Hands	CON		NO
Janet Anderson	LAB		NO
Jim Dowd	LAB		NO
Jim Fitzpatrick	LAB		NO
Jim McGovern	LAB		NO
John Penrose	CON		NO
Lembit Öpik	LD		NO
Mark Hunter	LD		NO
Martin Caton	LAB		NO
Michael Moore	LD		AYE
Mr Alan Reid	LD		NO
Mr Andrew Dismore	LAB		NO
Mr Colin Breed	LD		AYE
Mr David Hamilton	LAB		NO
Mr David Heath	LD		NO
Mr Dennis Skinner	LAB		NO
Mr John Leech	LD		NO
Mr Mark Williams	LD		NO
Mr Nicholas Brown	IND		NO
Mr Paul Truswell	LAB		NO
Mr Peter Ainsworth	CON		NO
Mr Philip Hollobone	CON		NO
Mr Siôn Simon	LAB		NO
Mrs Linda Riordan	LAB		NO
Nick Herbert			NO
Paul Holmes	LD		NO
Paul Rowen	LD		NO
Peter Lilley			NO
Philip Dunne	CON		NO
Richard Younger-Ross	LD		NO
Roger Williams	LD		NO
Sandra Gidley	LD		NO
Simon Hughes	LD		NO
Sir Bob Russell	LD		NO
Sir Geoffrey Cox	CON	Torridge and Tavistock	NO
Sir Gerald Howarth	CON		NO
Sir James Duddridge	CON		NO
Sir Lindsay Hoyle	SPE	Chorley	NO
Sir Oliver Heald	CON		NO
Sir Paul Beresford	CON		NO
Sir Peter Bottomley	CON		NO
Sir Richard Ottaway	CON		NO
Sir Robert Syms	CON		NO
Stephen Pound	LAB		NO
Steve McCabe			NO
Steve Webb	LD		NO
Tim Loughton	CON		NO
Tom Randall	CON		NO
Vernon Coaker			NO