On a point of order, Mr. Deputy Speaker. Does this debate not provide a good illustration of the fact that the entire Bill has been constructed in order to avoid hybrid instruments and the Hybrid Instruments Committee procedure, under which all these matters could be discussed in the proper manner? Is this not the true problem, and it will come out in the hybrid instruments— Order. That is not a m...

21 February 2008 #12456

Official page

279

Ayes

169

Noes

110

Majority

PASS

Result

Party breakdown

Party	Aye	No	Total
LAB Labour	224	1	225
CON Conservative	1	107	108
UNK Unknown	18	15	33
IND Independent	16	10	26
LD Liberal Democrat	2	15	17
SCO Scottish National Party	0	3	3
THE The Independent Group for Change	3	0	3
PC Plaid Cymru	0	2	2
SPE Speaker	1	0	1

How MPs voted

418 recorded

MP	Party	Constituency	Vote
Adam Afriyie	CON		NO
Adam Holloway	CON		NO
Adam Price	PC		NO
Alan Johnson	LAB		AYE
Alan Keen	LAB		AYE
Alan Whitehead			AYE
Alan Williams	LAB		AYE
Albert Owen	LAB		AYE
Alison Seabeck	LAB		AYE
Alistair Burt	CON		NO
Alun Michael	LAB		AYE
Andrew Gwynne	IND		AYE
Andrew Miller	LAB		AYE
Andrew Selous	CON		NO
Andy Burnham	LAB		AYE
Andy Slaughter	LAB	Hammersmith and Chiswick	AYE
Angela Smith	LD		AYE
Angus Brendan MacNeil	IND		NO
Angus Robertson	SCO		NO
Ann Clwyd	LAB		AYE
Ann Coffey	THE		AYE
Ann Keen	LAB		AYE
Ann McKechin	LAB		AYE
Anne Milton	IND		NO
Anne Moffat	LAB		AYE
Anne Snelgrove	LAB		AYE
Annette Brooke	LD		NO
Austin Mitchell	LAB		AYE
Barbara Follett	LAB		AYE
Barbara Keeley			AYE
Ben Chapman	LAB		AYE
Bill Rammell	LAB		AYE
Bob Spink	IND		NO
Bridget Prentice	LAB		AYE
Caroline Flint	LAB		AYE
Charles Hendry	CON		NO
Charlotte Atkins	LAB		AYE
Chris Bryant	LAB	Rhondda and Ogmore	AYE
Chris Huhne	LD		NO
Chris McCafferty	LAB		AYE
Chris Mole	LAB		AYE
Chris Ruane	LAB		AYE
Christine Russell	LAB		AYE
Christopher Fraser	CON		NO
Clive Efford	LAB	Eltham and Chislehurst	AYE
Colin Burgon	LAB		AYE
Colin Challen	LAB		AYE
Dame Angela Eagle	LAB	Wallasey	AYE
Dame Angela Watkinson	CON		NO
Dame Anne Begg	LAB		AYE
Dame Anne McGuire	LAB		AYE
Dame Cheryl Gillan	CON		NO
Dame Diana Johnson	LAB	Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham	AYE
Dame Louise Ellman	IND		AYE
Dame Maria Miller	CON		NO
Dame Meg Hillier	LAB	Hackney South and Shoreditch	AYE
Dame Nia Griffith	LAB	Llanelli	AYE
Dame Siobhain McDonagh	LAB	Mitcham and Morden	AYE
Damian Green	CON		NO
Dan Norris	IND	North East Somerset and Hanham	AYE
Daniel Kawczynski	CON		NO
David Cairns	LAB		AYE
David Hanson			AYE
David Heyes	LAB		AYE
David Lepper	LAB		AYE
David Mundell	CON	Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale	NO
David T C Davies	CON		NO
David Taylor	LAB		AYE
David Wright	LAB		AYE
Derek Twigg	LAB	Widnes and Halewood	AYE
Derek Wyatt	LAB		AYE
Dr Andrew Murrison	CON	South West Wiltshire	NO
Dr Ashok Kumar	LAB		AYE
Dr Brian Iddon	LAB		AYE
Dr David Drew	LAB		AYE
Dr Desmond Turner	LAB		AYE
Dr Doug Naysmith	LAB		AYE
Dr Gavin Strang	LAB		AYE
Dr Hywel Francis	LAB		AYE
Dr Ian Gibson	LAB		AYE
Dr Nick Palmer	LAB		AYE
Dr Phyllis Starkey	LAB		AYE
Dr Roberta Blackman-Woods	LAB		AYE
Dr Stephen Ladyman	LAB		AYE
Ed Balls	LAB		AYE
Ed Davey	LD	Kingston and Surbiton	NO
Ed Miliband	LAB	Doncaster North	AYE
Edward Garnier			NO
Edward Vaizey			NO
Eleanor Laing			NO
Eric Pickles			NO
Ernest Armstrong	LAB		AYE
Fabian Hamilton	LAB	Leeds North East	AYE
Fiona Mactaggart	LAB		AYE
Frank Cook	LAB		AYE
Frank Dobson	LAB		AYE
Frank Field			AYE
Gareth Thomas	LAB		AYE
Geraldine Smith	LAB		AYE
Gisela Stuart			AYE
Gordon Banks	LAB		AYE
Gordon Marsden	LAB		AYE
Graham Stringer	LAB	Blackley and Middleton South	AYE
Grant Shapps	CON		NO
Greg Clark	CON		NO
Greg Hands	CON		NO
Gwyn Prosser	LAB		AYE
Harriet Harman			AYE
Harry Cohen	LAB		AYE
Helen Goodman	LAB		NO
Helen Jones	LAB		AYE
Helen Southworth	LAB		AYE
Henry Bellingham			NO
Hilary Benn	LAB	Leeds South	AYE
Hugo Swire			NO
Huw Irranca-Davies	LAB		AYE
Ian C. Lucas	LAB		AYE
Ian Pearson	LAB		AYE
Ian Stewart	LAB		AYE
James Brokenshire	CON		NO
James Gray	CON		NO
James Purnell	LAB		AYE
Jane Kennedy	LAB		AYE
Janet Anderson	LAB		AYE
Jeff Ennis	LAB		AYE
Jenny Willott	LD		NO
Jeremy Corbyn	IND	Islington North	AYE
Jessica Morden	LAB	Newport East	AYE
Jim Cousins	LAB		AYE
Jim Dobbin	LAB		AYE
Jim Dowd	LAB		AYE
Jim Fitzpatrick	LAB		AYE
Jim McGovern	LAB		AYE
Jim Sheridan	LAB		AYE
Jo Swinson	LD		NO
Joan Ryan	THE		AYE
Joan Walley	LAB		AYE
John Austin	LAB		AYE
John Battle	LAB		AYE
John Cummings	LAB		AYE
John Grogan	LAB		AYE
John Healey	LAB	Rawmarsh and Conisbrough	AYE
John Mann			AYE
John Penrose	CON		NO
John Robertson	LAB		AYE
John Smith	LAB		AYE
John Spellar			AYE
John Watts	CON		AYE
Jon Cruddas	LAB		AYE
Jon Trickett	LAB	Normanton and Hemsworth	AYE
Jonathan Shaw	LAB		AYE
Judy Mallaber	LAB		AYE
Julia Goldsworthy	LD		NO
Julie Kirkbride	CON		NO
Julie Morgan	LAB		AYE
Justine Greening	IND		NO
Keith Vaz	LAB		AYE
Kelvin Hopkins	IND		AYE
Kenneth Clarke			NO
Kerry McCarthy	LAB	Bristol East	AYE
Kevan Jones			AYE
Kevin Brennan			AYE
Laura Moffatt	LAB		AYE
Lembit Öpik	LD		NO
Liam Byrne	LAB	Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North	AYE
Liz Blackman	LAB		AYE
Lyn Brown			AYE
Lynda Waltho	LAB		AYE
Malcolm Wicks	LAB		AYE
Margaret Beckett			AYE
Margaret Hodge			AYE
Margaret Moran	IND		AYE
Maria Eagle	LAB	Liverpool Garston	AYE
Mark Field	CON		NO
Mark Fisher	LAB		AYE
Mark Harper			NO
Mark Lancaster			NO
Mark Lazarowicz	LAB		AYE
Mark Pritchard	CON	The Wrekin	NO
Mark Simmonds	CON		NO
Martin Caton	LAB		AYE
Martin Linton	LAB		AYE
Martin Salter	LAB		AYE
Meg Munn	LAB		AYE
Michael Connarty	LAB		AYE
Michael Fabricant	CON		NO
Michael Jabez Foster	LAB		AYE
Mike Gapes	THE		AYE
Mike Weir	SCO		NO
Mike Wood	LAB		AYE
Miss Ann Widdecombe	CON		NO
Mr Adrian Bailey	LAB		AYE
Mr Alistair Carmichael	LD	Orkney and Shetland	NO
Mr Andrew Dismore	LAB		AYE
Mr Andrew Love	LAB		AYE
Mr Andrew Mackay	CON		NO
Mr Andrew Smith	LAB		AYE
Mr Andrew Turner	CON		NO
Mr Andy Reed	LAB		AYE
Mr Anthony Steen	CON		NO
Mr Anthony Wright	LAB		AYE
Mr Ben Bradshaw	LAB		AYE
Mr Ben Wallace	CON		NO
Mr Bill Olner	LAB		AYE
Mr Bob Ainsworth	LAB		AYE
Mr Bob Blizzard	LAB		AYE
Mr Bob Laxton	LAB		AYE
Mr Brian Binley	CON		NO
Mr Brian H. Donohoe	LAB		AYE
Mr Brian Jenkins	LAB		AYE
Mr Brooks Newmark	CON		NO
Mr Charles Clarke	LAB		AYE
Mr Chris Mullin	LAB		AYE
Mr Clive Betts	LAB	Sheffield South East	AYE
Mr Dai Davies	IND		AYE
Mr Dai Havard	LAB		AYE
Mr David Anderson	LAB		AYE
Mr David Burrowes	CON		NO
Mr David Chaytor	IND		AYE
Mr David Clelland	LAB		AYE
Mr David Curry	CON		NO
Mr David Gauke	IND		NO
Mr David Hamilton	LAB		AYE
Mr David Kidney	LAB		AYE
Mr David Lammy	LAB	Tottenham	AYE
Mr David Laws	LD		NO
Mr David Ruffley	CON		NO
Mr David S. Borrow	LAB		AYE
Mr David Winnick	LAB		AYE
Mr Denis MacShane	LAB		AYE
Mr Denis Murphy	LAB		AYE
Mr Dennis Skinner	LAB		AYE
Mr Dominic Grieve	IND		NO
Mr Doug Henderson	LAB		AYE
Mr Douglas Carswell	IND		NO
Mr Edward O'Hara	LAB		AYE
Mr Elfyn Llwyd	PC		NO
Mr Eric Illsley	IND		AYE
Mr Eric Martlew	LAB		AYE
Mr Frank Roy	LAB		AYE
Mr Fraser Kemp	LAB		AYE
Mr Geoffrey Hoon	IND		AYE
Mr Geoffrey Robinson	LAB		AYE
Mr George Mudie	LAB		AYE
Mr George Osborne	CON		NO
Mr Gerry Sutcliffe	LAB		AYE
Mr Gordon Prentice	LAB		AYE
Mr Greg Pope	LAB		AYE
Mr Humfrey Malins	CON		NO
Mr Iain Wright	LAB		AYE
Mr Ian Cawsey	LAB		AYE
Mr Ian Davidson	LAB		AYE
Mr Ian Liddell-Grainger	CON		NO
Mr Ian Taylor	CON		NO
Mr Ivan Lewis	IND		AYE
Mr Jack Straw	IND		AYE
Mr James Clappison	CON		NO
Mr James Plaskitt	LAB		AYE
Mr Jamie Reed	LAB		AYE
Mr Jeremy Browne	LD		NO
Mr Jim Cunningham	LAB		AYE
Mr Jim Devine	LAB		AYE
Mr Jim Hood	LAB		AYE
Mr Jim Murphy	LAB		AYE
Mr Joe Benton	LAB		AYE
Mr John Baron	CON		NO
Mr John Denham	LAB		AYE
Mr John Greenway	CON		NO
Mr John Heppell	LAB		AYE
Mr Jonathan Djanogly	CON		NO
Mr Keith Simpson	CON		NO
Mr Ken Purchase	LAB		AYE
Mr Khalid Mahmood	LAB		AYE
Mr Laurence Robertson	CON		NO
Mr Lee Scott	CON		NO
Mr Malcolm Moss	CON		NO
Mr Mark Francois	CON	Rayleigh and Wickford	NO
Mr Mark Hoban	CON		NO
Mr Mark Prisk	CON		NO
Mr Mark Todd	LAB		AYE
Mr Marsha Singh	LAB		AYE
Mr Michael Clapham	LAB		AYE
Mr Michael Foster	LAB		AYE
Mr Michael Meacher	LAB		AYE
Mr Mike Hall	LAB		AYE
Mr Nicholas Brown	IND		AYE
Mr Nick Raynsford	LAB		AYE
Mr Nigel Evans	CON		NO
Mr Nigel Waterson	CON		NO
Mr Parmjit Dhanda	LAB		AYE
Mr Peter Ainsworth	CON		NO
Mr Peter Atkinson	CON		NO
Mr Peter Bone	IND		NO
Mr Peter Kilfoyle	LAB		AYE
Mr Philip Hollobone	CON		NO
Mr Richard Bacon	CON		NO
Mr Richard Caborn	LAB		AYE
Mr Rob Wilson	CON		NO
Mr Ronnie Campbell	LAB		AYE
Mr Russell Brown	LAB		AYE
Mr Siôn Simon	LAB		AYE
Mr Stephen Hepburn	IND		AYE
Mr Terry Rooney	LAB		AYE
Mr Tim Yeo	CON		NO
Mr Tobias Ellwood	CON		NO
Mr Tom Harris	LAB		AYE
Mr Tony McNulty	LAB		AYE
Mr Virendra Sharma	LAB		AYE
Mrs Ann Cryer	LAB		AYE
Mrs Anne Main	CON		NO
Mrs Betty Williams	LAB		AYE
Mrs Jacqui Lait	CON		NO
Mrs Janet Dean	LAB		AYE
Mrs Joan Humble	LAB		AYE
Mrs Linda Riordan	LAB		AYE
Mrs Madeleine Moon	LAB		AYE
Mrs Sharon Hodgson	LAB	Washington and Gateshead South	AYE
Mrs Siân C. James	LAB		AYE
Ms Dari Taylor	LAB		AYE
Ms Diane Abbott	IND	Hackney North and Stoke Newington	AYE
Ms Patricia Hewitt	IND		AYE
Ms Sally Keeble	LAB		AYE
Nicholas Soames			NO
Nick Gibb	CON		NO
Nick Herbert			NO
Norman Baker	LD		NO
Paddy Tipping	LAB		AYE
Pat McFadden	LAB	Wolverhampton South East	AYE
Patrick Hall	LAB		AYE
Patrick McLoughlin			NO
Patrick Mercer	IND		NO
Paul Clark	LAB		AYE
Paul Flynn	LAB		AYE
Paul Goggins	LAB		AYE
Paul Holmes	LD		NO
Peter Lilley			NO
Phil Wilson			AYE
Philip Boswell	SCO		NO
Philip Dunne	CON		NO
Philip Hammond			NO
Richard Burden	LAB		AYE
Richard Younger-Ross	LD		NO
Rob Marris	LAB		AYE
Robert Flello	LAB		AYE
Robert Key	CON		NO
Roger Berry	LAB		AYE
Rosemary McKenna	LAB		AYE
Rosie Cooper	LAB		AYE
Rosie Winterton			AYE
Sadiq Khan	LAB		AYE
Sandra Gidley	LD		NO
Sarah McCarthy-Fry	LAB		AYE
Shailesh Vara	CON		NO
Shona McIsaac	LAB		AYE
Simon Hughes	LD		NO
Sir Alan Campbell	LAB	Tynemouth	AYE
Sir Bill Wiggin	CON		NO
Sir Charles Walker	CON		NO
Sir Christopher Chope	CON	Christchurch	NO
Sir David Amess	CON		NO
Sir David Crausby	LAB		AYE
Sir David Evennett	CON		NO
Sir David Lidington	CON		NO
Sir Desmond Swayne	CON	New Forest West	NO
Sir Edward Leigh	CON	Gainsborough	NO
Sir Gary Streeter	CON		NO
Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown	CON	North Cotswolds	NO
Sir George Howarth	LAB		AYE
Sir George Younger	CON		NO
Sir Gerald Howarth	CON		NO
Sir Greg Knight	CON		NO
Sir Hugh Robertson	CON		NO
Sir Iain Duncan Smith	CON	Chingford and Woodford Green	NO
Sir James Duddridge	CON		NO
Sir James Spicer	CON		NO
Sir Jeremy Hunt	CON	Godalming and Ash	NO
Sir Jeremy Wright	CON	Kenilworth and Southam	NO
Sir John Butterfill	CON		NO
Sir John Hayes	CON	South Holland and The Deepings	NO
Sir John Redwood	CON		NO
Sir John Stanley	CON		NO
Sir John Whittingdale	CON	Maldon	NO
Sir Julian Brazier	CON		NO
Sir Julian Lewis	CON	New Forest East	NO
Sir Kevin Barron	LAB		AYE
Sir Liam Fox	CON		NO
Sir Lindsay Hoyle	SPE	Chorley	AYE
Sir Mike Penning	CON		NO
Sir Oliver Heald	CON		NO
Sir Oliver Letwin	IND		NO
Sir Paul Beresford	CON		NO
Sir Peter Soulsby	LAB		AYE
Sir Philip Davies	CON		NO
Sir Richard Shepherd	CON		NO
Sir Robert Neill	CON		NO
Sir Robert Syms	CON		NO
Sir Roger Gale	CON	Herne Bay and Sandwich	NO
Sir Simon Burns	CON		NO
Sir Stephen Timms	LAB	East Ham	AYE
Sir Stuart Bell	LAB		AYE
Sir Tony Baldry	CON		NO
Sir Tony Cunningham	LAB		AYE
Sir William Cash	CON		NO
Stephen Hammond	CON		NO
Stephen Hesford	LAB		AYE
Stephen Pound	LAB		AYE
Steve Darling	LD	Torbay	AYE
Steve McCabe			AYE
Theresa May			NO
Theresa Villiers	CON		NO
Tim Loughton	CON		NO
Tom Levitt	LAB		AYE
Tom Randall	CON		NO
Tom Watson			AYE
Vera Baird	LAB		AYE
Vernon Coaker			AYE
Wayne David	LAB		AYE
Yvette Cooper	LAB	Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley	AYE