← Back to Divisions
commons

My problem is that it is very difficult to compare costs. I intervened on the hon. Gentleman and, perhaps rashly, he insisted that he was comparing like with like. I ask him to think again. It is very difficult to make reliable comparisons for exactly the reason that has been given by the hon. Member for Somerton and Frome (Mr. Heath) . There is no like-for-like comparison that we have been able t...

4 November 2009 #13030
152
Ayes
332
Noes
180
Majority
FAIL
Result

Party breakdown

Party Aye No Other Total
LAB Labour 3 223 0 226
CON Conservative 109 1 0 110
LD Liberal Democrat 0 42 0 42
UNK Unknown 17 18 0 35
IND Independent 9 16 0 25
SCO Scottish National Party 1 2 0 3
THE The Independent Group for Change 0 3 0 3
PC Plaid Cymru 0 2 0 2
DUP Democratic Unionist Party 2 0 0 2
LAB Social Democratic & Labour Party 0 1 0 1

How MPs voted

449 recorded
MP Party Constituency Vote
Adam Afriyie CON AYE
Adam Holloway CON AYE
Alan Keen LAB NO
Alan Whitehead NO
Alan Williams LAB NO
Albert Owen LAB NO
Alison Seabeck LAB NO
Alistair Burt CON AYE
Alun Michael LAB NO
Andrew George LD St Ives NO
Andrew Gwynne IND NO
Andrew Mackinlay LAB NO
Andrew Miller LAB NO
Andrew Selous CON AYE
Andy Slaughter LAB Hammersmith and Chiswick NO
Angela Smith LD NO
Angus Brendan MacNeil IND NO
Angus Robertson SCO NO
Ann Clwyd LAB NO
Ann Coffey THE NO
Ann Keen LAB NO
Ann Winterton CON AYE
Anne Snelgrove LAB NO
Annette Brooke LD NO
Austin Mitchell LAB NO
Barbara Follett LAB NO
Barbara Keeley NO
Barry Gardiner LAB Brent West NO
Ben Chapman LAB NO
Ben Gummer CON AYE
Bill Etherington LAB NO
Bridget Prentice LAB NO
Caroline Flint LAB NO
Charles Hendry CON AYE
Charlotte Atkins LAB NO
Chloe Smith CON AYE
Chris Bryant LAB Rhondda and Ogmore NO
Chris Huhne LD NO
Chris McCafferty LAB NO
Chris Mole LAB NO
Chris Ruane LAB NO
Christopher Fraser CON AYE
Claire Ward LAB NO
Clive Efford LAB Eltham and Chislehurst NO
Colin Challen LAB NO
Dame Angela Eagle LAB Wallasey NO
Dame Angela Watkinson CON AYE
Dame Anne Begg LAB NO
Dame Anne McGuire LAB NO
Dame Cheryl Gillan CON AYE
Dame Diana Johnson LAB Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham NO
Dame Joan Ruddock LAB NO
Dame Louise Ellman IND NO
Dame Maria Miller CON AYE
Dame Meg Hillier LAB Hackney South and Shoreditch NO
Dame Nia Griffith LAB Llanelli NO
Dame Siobhain McDonagh LAB Mitcham and Morden NO
Daniel Kawczynski CON AYE
David Cairns LAB NO
David Davis CON Goole and Pocklington AYE
David Hanson NO
David Heyes LAB NO
David Howarth LD NO
David Lepper LAB NO
David Mundell CON Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale AYE
David T C Davies CON AYE
David Taylor LAB NO
David Tredinnick CON AYE
David Wright LAB NO
Dawn Butler LAB Brent East NO
Dr Ashok Kumar LAB NO
Dr Brian Iddon LAB NO
Dr Desmond Turner LAB NO
Dr Evan Harris LD NO
Dr Howard Stoate LAB NO
Dr Hywel Francis LAB NO
Dr Kim Howells LAB NO
Dr Nick Palmer LAB NO
Dr Phyllis Starkey LAB NO
Dr Richard Taylor IND NO
Dr Roberta Blackman-Woods LAB NO
Dr Stephen Ladyman LAB NO
Dr Tony Wright LAB NO
Ed Balls LAB NO
Ed Davey LD Kingston and Surbiton NO
Ed Miliband LAB Doncaster North NO
Edward Garnier AYE
Edward Timpson CON AYE
Edward Vaizey AYE
Eleanor Laing AYE
Emily Thornberry LAB Islington South and Finsbury NO
Eric Joyce IND NO
Eric Pickles AYE
Fabian Hamilton LAB Leeds North East NO
Fiona Mactaggart LAB NO
Frank Cook LAB NO
Frank Dobson LAB NO
Frank Field NO
Gareth Thomas LAB NO
Geraldine Smith LAB NO
Gisela Stuart NO
Gordon Banks LAB NO
Gordon Marsden LAB NO
Graham Brady AYE
Graham Stringer LAB Blackley and Middleton South NO
Graham Stuart CON Beverley and Holderness AYE
Grant Shapps CON AYE
Greg Clark CON AYE
Greg Hands CON AYE
Greg Mulholland LD NO
Gwyn Prosser LAB NO
Harriet Harman NO
Hazel Blears LAB NO
Helen Goodman LAB AYE
Helen Jones LAB NO
Helen Southworth LAB NO
Henry Bellingham AYE
Hilary Benn LAB Leeds South NO
Hugo Swire AYE
Hywel Williams PC NO
Ian Austin NO
Ian C. Lucas LAB NO
Ian Pearson LAB NO
Ian Stewart LAB NO
James Gray CON AYE
James Purnell LAB NO
Jane Kennedy LAB NO
Jeff Ennis LAB NO
Jenny Willott LD NO
Jeremy Corbyn IND Islington North NO
Jessica Morden LAB Newport East NO
Jim Cousins LAB NO
Jim Dobbin LAB NO
Jim Fitzpatrick LAB NO
Jim McGovern LAB NO
Jim Sheridan LAB NO
Jo Swinson LD NO
Joan Ryan THE NO
Joan Walley LAB NO
John Barrett LD NO
John Cummings LAB NO
John Grogan LAB NO
John Healey LAB Rawmarsh and Conisbrough NO
John Hemming LD NO
John Howell CON AYE
John Mann NO
John McDonnell LAB Hayes and Harlington NO
John Penrose CON AYE
John Pugh LD NO
John Robertson LAB NO
John Spellar NO
John Watts CON NO
Jon Cruddas LAB NO
Jon Trickett LAB Normanton and Hemsworth NO
Jonathan Shaw LAB NO
Judy Mallaber LAB NO
Julie Kirkbride CON AYE
Justine Greening IND AYE
Kali Mountford LAB NO
Kate Hoey NO
Kelvin Hopkins IND NO
Kenneth Clarke AYE
Kerry McCarthy LAB Bristol East NO
Kevin Brennan NO
Kitty Ussher LAB NO
Lady Hermon IND AYE
Laura Moffatt LAB NO
Lembit Öpik LD NO
Liam Byrne LAB Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North NO
Linda Gilroy LAB NO
Lindsay Roy LAB NO
Liz Blackman LAB NO
Lyn Brown NO
Lynda Waltho LAB NO
Lynne Jones LAB NO
Malcolm Wicks LAB NO
Margaret Beckett NO
Maria Eagle LAB Liverpool Garston NO
Mark Durkan LAB NO
Mark Fisher LAB NO
Mark Harper AYE
Mark Hunter LD NO
Mark Lazarowicz LAB NO
Mark Pritchard CON The Wrekin AYE
Mark Simmonds CON AYE
Martin Caton LAB NO
Martin Horwood LD NO
Martin Linton LAB NO
Mary Creagh LAB Coventry East NO
Meg Munn LAB NO
Michael Connarty LAB NO
Michael Fabricant CON AYE
Michael Gove AYE
Michael Jabez Foster LAB NO
Michael Moore LD NO
Mike Gapes THE NO
Mike Wood LAB NO
Mr Adrian Bailey LAB NO
Mr Adrian Sanders LD NO
Mr Alan Reid LD NO
Mr Alistair Carmichael LD Orkney and Shetland NO
Mr Andrew Love LAB NO
Mr Andrew Smith LAB NO
Mr Andrew Turner CON AYE
Mr Andy Reed LAB NO
Mr Anthony Steen CON AYE
Mr Anthony Wright LAB NO
Mr Barry Sheerman LAB NO
Mr Ben Bradshaw LAB NO
Mr Ben Wallace CON AYE
Mr Bob Blizzard LAB NO
Mr Bob Laxton LAB NO
Mr Brian Binley CON AYE
Mr Brian Jenkins LAB NO
Mr Brooks Newmark CON AYE
Mr Chris Mullin LAB NO
Mr Clive Betts LAB Sheffield South East NO
Mr Dai Davies IND NO
Mr Dai Havard LAB NO
Mr David Burrowes CON AYE
Mr David Clelland LAB NO
Mr David Curry CON AYE
Mr David Gauke IND AYE
Mr David Hamilton LAB NO
Mr David Heath LD NO
Mr David Heathcoat-Amory CON AYE
Mr David Jones CON AYE
Mr David Kidney LAB NO
Mr David Lammy LAB Tottenham NO
Mr David Ruffley CON AYE
Mr David S. Borrow LAB NO
Mr Denis Murphy LAB NO
Mr Dennis Skinner LAB NO
Mr Dominic Grieve IND AYE
Mr Doug Henderson LAB NO
Mr Douglas Alexander LAB Lothian East NO
Mr Douglas Carswell IND AYE
Mr Edward O'Hara LAB NO
Mr Elfyn Llwyd PC NO
Mr Elliot Morley LAB NO
Mr Eric Illsley IND NO
Mr Eric Martlew LAB NO
Mr Frank Doran LAB NO
Mr Fraser Kemp LAB NO
Mr Geoffrey Hoon IND NO
Mr Geoffrey Robinson LAB NO
Mr George Mudie LAB NO
Mr Gordon Prentice LAB NO
Mr Graham Allen LAB NO
Mr Greg Pope LAB NO
Mr Ian Cawsey LAB NO
Mr Ian Davidson LAB NO
Mr Ian Liddell-Grainger CON AYE
Mr Ian Taylor CON AYE
Mr Jack Straw IND NO
Mr James Clappison CON AYE
Mr James Plaskitt LAB NO
Mr Jamie Reed LAB NO
Mr Jeremy Browne LD NO
Mr Jim Cunningham LAB NO
Mr Jim Hood LAB NO
Mr Joe Benton LAB NO
Mr John Baron CON AYE
Mr John Denham LAB NO
Mr John Heppell LAB NO
Mr John Leech LD NO
Mr Jonathan Djanogly CON AYE
Mr Keith Simpson CON AYE
Mr Ken Purchase LAB NO
Mr Laurence Robertson CON AYE
Mr Lee Scott CON AYE
Mr Malcolm Moss CON AYE
Mr Mark Hoban CON AYE
Mr Mark Prisk CON AYE
Mr Mark Todd LAB NO
Mr Mark Williams LD NO
Mr Michael Clapham LAB NO
Mr Michael Foster LAB NO
Mr Michael Jack CON AYE
Mr Michael Meacher LAB NO
Mr Mike Hall LAB NO
Mr Mike O'Brien LAB NO
Mr Mohammad Sarwar LAB NO
Mr Neil Gerrard LAB NO
Mr Neil Turner LAB NO
Mr Nicholas Brown IND NO
Mr Nick Clegg LD NO
Mr Nick Hurd CON AYE
Mr Nick Raynsford LAB NO
Mr Nigel Waterson CON AYE
Mr Owen Paterson CON AYE
Mr Parmjit Dhanda LAB NO
Mr Paul Keetch LD NO
Mr Paul Truswell LAB NO
Mr Peter Ainsworth CON AYE
Mr Peter Atkinson CON AYE
Mr Peter Bone IND AYE
Mr Peter Kilfoyle LAB NO
Mr Peter Robinson DUP AYE
Mr Philip Hollobone CON AYE
Mr Richard Caborn LAB NO
Mr Russell Brown LAB NO
Mr Shahid Malik LAB NO
Mr Shaun Woodward LAB NO
Mr Stephen Byers IND NO
Mr Stephen Dorrell CON AYE
Mr Stephen Hepburn IND NO
Mr Stephen O'Brien CON AYE
Mr Terry Rooney LAB NO
Mr Tobias Ellwood CON AYE
Mr Tom Clarke LAB NO
Mr Tony McNulty LAB NO
Mrs Ann Cryer LAB NO
Mrs Anne Main CON AYE
Mrs Claire Curtis-Thomas LAB NO
Mrs Iris Robinson IND AYE
Mrs Jacqui Lait CON AYE
Mrs Janet Dean LAB NO
Mrs Joan Humble LAB NO
Mrs Linda Riordan LAB NO
Mrs Madeleine Moon LAB NO
Mrs Sharon Hodgson LAB Washington and Gateshead South NO
Mrs Siân C. James LAB NO
Ms Celia Barlow LAB NO
Ms Dari Taylor LAB NO
Ms Diane Abbott IND Hackney North and Stoke Newington NO
Ms Karen Buck LAB NO
Ms Nadine Dorries CON AYE
Ms Patricia Hewitt IND NO
Ms Sally Keeble LAB NO
Natascha Engel LAB NO
Nick Ainger LAB NO
Nick Gibb CON AYE
Nick Herbert AYE
Nigel Dodds AYE
Nigel Griffiths LAB NO
Norman Hogg LAB AYE
Paddy Tipping LAB NO
Pat McFadden LAB Wolverhampton South East NO
Patrick Hall LAB NO
Patrick McLoughlin AYE
Patrick Mercer IND AYE
Paul Burstow LD NO
Paul Clark LAB NO
Paul Farrelly LAB NO
Paul Flynn LAB NO
Paul Goggins LAB NO
Paul Holmes LD NO
Paul Rowen LD NO
Paula Barker LAB Liverpool Wavertree AYE
Pete Wishart SCO Perth and Kinross-shire NO
Phil Wilson NO
Philip Boswell SCO AYE
Philip Dunne CON AYE
Philip Hammond AYE
Rachel Maclean AYE
Richard Burden LAB NO
Richard Younger-Ross LD NO
Rob Marris LAB NO
Robert Flello LAB NO
Robert Key CON AYE
Roger Berry LAB NO
Roger Williams LD NO
Rosemary McKenna LAB NO
Rosie Cooper LAB NO
Rosie Winterton NO
Ruth Kelly LAB NO
Sadiq Khan LAB NO
Sammy Wilson DUP East Antrim AYE
Sandra Gidley LD NO
Sandra Osborne LAB NO
Sarah McCarthy-Fry LAB NO
Sarah Teather LD NO
Shailesh Vara CON AYE
Shona McIsaac LAB NO
Simon Hughes LD NO
Sir Alan Campbell LAB Tynemouth NO
Sir Alan Duncan CON AYE
Sir Alan Meale LAB NO
Sir Andrew Mitchell CON Sutton Coldfield AYE
Sir Bernard Jenkin CON Harwich and North Essex AYE
Sir Bob Russell LD NO
Sir Christopher Chope CON Christchurch AYE
Sir David Amess CON AYE
Sir David Crausby LAB NO
Sir David Evennett CON AYE
Sir David Lidington CON AYE
Sir Edward Leigh CON Gainsborough AYE
Sir Gary Streeter CON AYE
Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown CON North Cotswolds AYE
Sir George Howarth LAB NO
Sir George Younger CON AYE
Sir Gerald Kaufman LAB NO
Sir Greg Knight CON AYE
Sir Ian McCartney LAB NO
Sir James Duddridge CON AYE
Sir James Paice CON AYE
Sir James Spicer CON AYE
Sir Jeffrey M Donaldson IND AYE
Sir Jeremy Hunt CON Godalming and Ash AYE
Sir Jeremy Wright CON Kenilworth and Southam AYE
Sir John Butterfill CON AYE
Sir John Redwood CON AYE
Sir John Stanley CON AYE
Sir John Whittingdale CON Maldon AYE
Sir Julian Brazier CON AYE
Sir Julian Lewis CON New Forest East AYE
Sir Kevin Barron LAB NO
Sir Mark Tami LAB Alyn and Deeside NO
Sir Michael Fallon CON AYE
Sir Mike Penning CON AYE
Sir Nick Harvey LD NO
Sir Oliver Heald CON AYE
Sir Paul Beresford CON AYE
Sir Peter Bottomley CON AYE
Sir Peter Luff CON AYE
Sir Peter Soulsby LAB NO
Sir Peter Tapsell CON AYE
Sir Peter Viggers CON AYE
Sir Philip Davies CON AYE
Sir Richard Ottaway CON AYE
Sir Richard Shepherd CON AYE
Sir Robert Goodwill CON AYE
Sir Robert Smith LD NO
Sir Robert Syms CON AYE
Sir Roger Gale CON Herne Bay and Sandwich AYE
Sir Simon Burns CON AYE
Sir Stephen Timms LAB East Ham NO
Sir Stuart Bell LAB NO
Sir Tony Baldry CON AYE
Sir Tony Cunningham LAB NO
Sir Vince Cable LD NO
Sir William Cash CON AYE
Stephen Crabb CON AYE
Stephen Hesford LAB NO
Stephen Williams LD NO
Steve McCabe NO
Steve Webb LD NO
Stewart Jackson AYE
Theresa May AYE
Theresa Villiers CON AYE
Tim Farron LD Westmorland and Lonsdale NO
Tom Brake LD NO
Tom Levitt LAB NO
Tom Watson NO
Tony Lloyd LAB NO
Vera Baird LAB NO
Vernon Coaker NO
Wayne David LAB NO